Feature #89223
open
Using columnsOnly creates a button to edit whole record.....
0%
Description
It has been a mystery to me for years why a "Edit whole record" button is created when 'columnsOnly' is used as parameter in links to edit various TCA records...
In my mind; 'columnsOnly' should restrict the editor to ONLY see these columns.....?!?!!?
In sysext/backend/Classes/Controller/EditDocumentController.php at line 1413:
// If only SOME fields are shown in the form, this will link the user to the FULL form:
if ($this->columnsOnly) {
$columnsOnlyButton = $buttonBar->makeLinkButton()
->setHref($this->R_URI . '&columnsOnly=')
->setTitle($lang->getLL('editWholeRecord'))
->setIcon($this->moduleTemplate->getIconFactory()->getIcon(
'actions-open',
Icon::SIZE_SMALL
));
$buttonBar->addButton($columnsOnlyButton, ButtonBar::BUTTON_POSITION_LEFT, 3);
}
Could some sort of extra configuration be added (&disableWholeRecord=1)
Files
Updated by Oliver Bartsch about 4 years ago
Hi,
columnsOnly is used to render records with limited fields for e.g. better overview because only some fields are needed in a specific context.
This means, columnsOnly is not the tool to restrict fields for editors. This is must be done by usergroup permissions (ACL: non_exclude_fields).
Therefore it's valid in my eyes that the "Edit record button" gets rendered here because if permissions are set correctly the "whole record" will also be limited.
Updated by Benni Mack about 4 years ago
- Status changed from New to Needs Feedback
Correct. This columnsOnly is to only add a specific selection of fields (possible from coming from the list module). Regarding permission this is not the way to go. Does setting proper permission solve your case? Or you could disable fields on a per-page/per-user basis with TSconfig?
Updated by Claus Harup about 4 years ago
The smart thing would be to add a possibility to set the parameter saying: ......&columnsOnly=title,abstract&hideEditWholeRecord=1
Updated by Benni Mack about 4 years ago
Claus Harup wrote:
The smart thing would be to add a possibility to set the parameter saying: ......&columnsOnly=title,abstract&hideEditWholeRecord=1
Sure, but why? This covers the visibility but people could work around that (badly) by using any other module.
Updated by Claus Harup about 4 years ago
Let us say I create a be module (*) and I want my editors to see a list of fe_users and ONLY want them to alter username and password - NO OTHER FIELDS!!!! :-)
(*) This module is THE ONLY module they can access when logged in.
Updated by Oliver Bartsch about 4 years ago
Hi, sorry for getting back to you so late.
Regarding your feedback, what about adding a backend user group for these editors only allowing them to edit the username and password field. Does this work for you?
Updated by Claus Harup about 4 years ago
Unforetunately no :-(
...adding &hideEditWholeRecord=1 would solve ANY variants of functionalities IMO.
Try to imagine, that you would like to create 2 be modules and in the first you would like to create a link like columnsOnly=username and in the other columnsOnly=password.... and I ONLY want these fields in the form...... - plain and simple :-)
Updated by Daniel Gohlke 6 months ago
@Claus Harup We had an similar issue. We only want editors to be able to edit one field from a backend module. They should not have access to the other fields. This could also be regulated with corresponding access rights of the user groups, but not further restricted for a module.
In TYPO3 v12.4 and v13.1 we have used the \TYPO3\CMS\Backend\Template\Components\ModifyButtonBarEvent and removed the corresponding button before rendering in case we come from the module.
As far as I could understand, this already works in TYPO3 v11.5 with the $GLOBALS['TYPO3_CONF_VARS']['SC_OPTIONS']['Backend\Template\Components\ButtonBar']['getButtonsHook'].
The button is then located in the array in the left position and in group 7 in all TYPO3 versions mentioned.
Unfortunately, we still have the problem that the Language Selector does not offer the possibility to change this, because it ignores the columnsOnly parameter. I will open a separate ticket for this and see if I can provide a patch for it.
Can the ticket be closed with this information?
Updated by Claus Harup 6 months ago
Not in my opinion.... the field says: "columns Only"
I still find it odd that TYPO3 offers a button for ALL fields