Feature #101124
closed
Make Templates optional in Extbase
0%
Description
Since ResponseInterface has been introduced, one can define a return type, JsonResponse , HtmlResponse etc.
The problem here is that using for example JsonResponse with Extbase and not defining a template for it, TYPO3 throws an exception. Now, we have to add a template and format it to a json structure which could be PITA, specially when the JSON is huge. One could use Middlewares , but with TYPO3 12, one can not use Extbase features if not in Extbase context. So now we are in a dead end.
Solution
Make the template requirement optional, or add a method which deactivates it for the action, like
$this->view->withTemplate(false);
Files
Updated by Aristeidis Karavas over 1 year ago
- Tags changed from extbase, JsonView to extbase, JsonResponse, HtmlResponse, view, template
Updated by Stefan Froemken over 1 year ago
- File Bildschirmfoto 2023-06-24 um 12.43.33.png Bildschirmfoto 2023-06-24 um 12.43.33.png added
- Status changed from New to Needs Feedback
- Assignee set to Stefan Froemken
Hello,
thank you for that information.
I have just tried to reproduce that problem, but I don't get any error message.
Please have a look into my uploaded picture here. There is no TypoScript, I return a JsonResponse and I have renamed the template for given action. I works like expected.
So please add some further information how to reproduce this issue.
Stefan
Updated by Aristeidis Karavas over 1 year ago
As explained in the description, the problem is when you do NOT define a template for a JSON response. Why would we need a template for json in the first place. Json has only one structure, a string. No need for any templating.
Updated by Stefan Froemken over 1 year ago
Hello Karavas,
as I have written: I have deactivated all templates to test your issue. Please have a look into my uploaded picture. There is a return statement in row 35. So all other lines behind are not executed.
I need further information from you on how to reprocuce your issue.
Stefan
Updated by Christian Hackl over 1 year ago
Stefan Froemken wrote in #note-4:
Hello Karavas,
as I have written: I have deactivated all templates to test your issue. Please have a look into my uploaded picture. There is a return statement in row 35. So all other lines behind are not executed.
I need further information from you on how to reprocuce your issue.
Stefan
Can you please adjust this minimal example extension (https://github.com/Hauer-Heinrich/ext_key) accordingly? i don't get it either :)
Thank you!
Updated by Benni Mack over 1 year ago
- Related to Feature #101125: Ability to convert Domain Models to Array added
Updated by Georg Ringer 6 months ago
- Status changed from Needs Feedback to Closed
closing the issue because lack of feedback. if still valid, please create a new issue and reference this one.
can't reproduce it either