Bug #88227
closed
f:form with noCache=1 causes cHash Errors
0%
Description
When you have a form like <f:form pageUid="1" action="myAction" controller="myController" noCache="1">...</form>
then the core will not generate a cHash. If the form is being sent, then the FrontendRequestHandler will throw a 404 when the $GLOBALS['TYPO3_CONF_VARS']['FE']['pageNotFoundOnCHashError'] is defined. In my opinion is a real problem, because sometimes you have a searchform which should show the matching results. The results itself can change everytime. So you have to clear the frontend cache to show the most recent results. Because of other not so much relevant informations on the page it does not make sense to set the page itself to uncached. So you have to set the searchform itself to sendout a no_cache=1 flag. But as I descriped above causes a 404 error. Another alternative would be to set the complete plugin (searchform with the results itself) to ignore the cHash. This is working, but you dont want to open this door, because of security. So another solution is needed here. I think if the form is generating a chash as long no "noCHash=1" set, then you donÄt have that problem.
Updated by Timo Pfeffer over 5 years ago
The "noCacheHash=1" attribute causes the same error
Updated by Christoph Lehmann over 5 years ago
Setting noCache=1 is really bad in general and may not make sense as a viewhelper argument anymore since extbase parameters require a cHash since 8.7 or so.
Adding your target action in non-cachable actions should solve your problem.
\TYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Utility\ExtensionUtility::configurePlugin(
'Vendor.extension_name',
'Storemap',
array(
'StoreList' => 'list',
),
// non-cacheable actions
array(
'StoreList' => 'list',
)
);
Setting noCacheHash="1" may only be used when you have method="get" with dynamic parameters (like of a search form)
Updated by Benni Mack almost 5 years ago
- Status changed from New to Closed
Christoph's recommendation is correct. In addition, TYPO3 v9's cHash implementation should show you that you don't need to deal with cHash anymore anyways. so I will close this issue for now. AFAICS this only affects TYPO3 v8. If you feel that this is not fixed yet, let me know and I will re-open the ticket.