TYPO3 Core

--deleted

I think that's the kind of customisation, which can easily be done using a tiny extension (so tiny that it can even be created by an integrator, not even a PHP developer).

Everybody thinks that "his" field is the most important one and should be integrated into the core - and then we end up with a 200 column pages table.. so -1 from my side.

Gentlemen. Just to make one thing sure. I first added the field I need to my pages table and THEN issued the feature request. Why? Because I'm trying to improve TYPO3. Are you too?

I have no problem at all if fields which are not needed are getting removed. I'm talking about a new field which might be needed, and I'm not asking for a field for my cat's birthday.

Besides that, currently other fields are added, like categories. With no documentation available until the time being.

Could have lived with a sentence like “well, I'll talk with the specialists from FE rendering or semantics. If they don't support the idea, I'll probably reject it”. But I didn't hear it. Instead I have learned, that Philip Gampe is in the position to reject any request “within a couple of days”. Do it now. I'm out of this Core issue Kindergarden – total waste of time.

@Thomas: First of all, I am the "Friendly Ghost" is this week. One of my task is to review and potentially close (new) issues in the issue tracker.

Second, we have a certain vision for TYPO3 CMS and we do exchange ideas, even if not all of this is public in first place.

Anyway, you fail to provide a good reason for this addition, besides "I need this" and "there are already other fields like this" which is both a "non-argument" for a serious discussion.

Third, you already good opposition in the list as well as from another another team member. If you fail to create a lobby for a feature only you need, how do you expect that this will land in core?
I leave this open so that you can create that kind of lobby, even if this is just to show that you are not the only one who needs this feature.

• why this is needed and what does it do
• how does this ease the work with TYPO3
• why can't this be easily added by extension [this is where you fail most]

You got opposition for all points already, thus if you need this, then please provide some arguments.

@Philipp

Well, just to avoid that another lie is cast into concrete here:
You know and I know that my feature request had a long and detailed prologue under forum.typo3.org the day before yesterday (look for "Page Class für Navigationselemente"). You even took an unfriendly part in it, as anyone can see who is able to read German. You could have answered my question about "categories" - I asked twice and got no answer - but you never did.
I already have “my field” (the one nobody except me needs), and there is no reason at all to create a lobby. Like I said, I'm out of it here, not disturbing the Core people's “certain visions for TYPO3 CMS” anymore.

ping