Story #75681
closed
connected mode: add new elements in alternative language
0%
Description
As an editor working in a translation in connected mode (translation mode) i should not be able to add new content elements in the linked alternative language
Acceptance Criteria:
• in page module Button „Content“ (new content element“ is in alternative language should not be visible
• in page module the option „More Options …/New Content Wizard“ in context menu should not be visible
• in list module the option „Create new record after this record“ should not be visible
Files
Updated by Riccardo De Contardi over 6 years ago
I tried with 8.7.9 and an admin user, on a TYPO3 installation with two languages
Test setup:¶
- create a new page
- translate it into the alternative language
- create a content element in default language
- translate it into alternative language using "translate" option
This should be sufficient to trigger the "connected" mode for that page
Results¶
- page module > switch language to alternative language > there is no button to create a new element
- page module > switch language to alternative language > click on the icon of the content element > you still see the "new" icon - if you click on it and save a new element, you will create an inconsistency (see attached screenshot)
- page module > switch language to alternative language > click on the icon of the content element > you still see the icon "More Options …/New Content Wizard" - if you click on it and create a new element you will create an inconsistency (same as previous screenshot)
- page module > switch language to alternative language > edit the content element > there is still the "save and create a new one" option - if you click on it and save a new element, you will create an inconsistency (same as previous screenshot)
So, I would add this last point to the acceptance criteria.
in list module the option „Create new record after this record“ should not be visible
I have not fully understood the scenario here.
Updated by Rens Admiraal about 6 years ago
- Related to Bug #84752: The "save and new" button can be used while in connected translation mode added
Updated by Riccardo De Contardi over 5 years ago
I've repeated the last test I've done on TYPO3 10.0.0 (latest master)
Test setup:¶
- create a new page
- translate it into the alternative language
- create a content element in default language
- translate it into alternative language using "translate" option
Results¶
- page module > switch language to alternative language > there is no button to create a new element
- page module > switch language to alternative language > click on the icon of the content element > you still see the "new" icon - if you click on it and save a new element, you will create an inconsistency (see attached screenshot)
- page module > switch language to alternative language > click on the icon of the content element > you still see the icon "More Options …/New Content Wizard" - if you click on it and create a new element you will create an inconsistency (same as previous screenshot)
- page module > switch language to alternative language > edit the content element > thanks to the refactoring of the "save" buttons, the "new" button on the top is absent
I have also performed the following new test:¶
- List view > click on the icon of the content in the default language > in the context menu you have the "new" icon; if you click on it and create a new content element, you will create a content element in the default language
- List view > click on the icon of the content in the default language > in the context menu you have the "More Options …/New Content Wizard" icon; if you click on it and create a new content element, you will create a content element in the default language
- List view > click on the icon of the content in the alternative language > in the context menu you have the "new" icon; if you click on it and create a new content element, you will create an inconsistency (see previously attached screenshot)
- List view > click on the icon of the content in the default language > in the context menu you have the "More Options …/New Content Wizard" icon; if you click on it and create a new content element, you will create an inconsistency (see previously attached screenshot)
Updated by Susanne Moog about 4 years ago
- Status changed from New to Closed
I'm going to close this issue because it's scope is to broad currently and the wanted behaviour is not clearly defined. Creating inconsistencies / mixed mode is possible and will result in the warning in Riccardos screenshot. However, as the warning states: "Make sure this behaviour is intended" < we consider that there might be cases, where this mix is wanted currently. Up until we change that, this ticket is superfluous.