Bug #16572
closed
Limit to Languages doesn't restrict editing of "alternative page language records"
0%
Description
Imagine 2 languages: default + german
English author creates page and content.
German translator creates "Alternative Page Language"-record in order to translate. Then he localizes the content.
Now the english author with "Limit to Languages" set to "default" is able to edit the german "Alternative Page Language"-record. He is even able to delete it!
Please confirm this major bug to get it fixed quickly!
tested on current DEV-Version and Release 4.0.2 + 4.0.0
(issue imported from #M4242)
Updated by Sebastian Kurfuerst almost 18 years ago
Hi everybody,
I did some research for that bug and I have made the following two testcases:
Group1: LimitToLanguages nothing selected
- User 1: Limit to default language
- User 2: Limit to 2nd language
In this test case, the error occurs. I presume it happens because at the group level, nothing is selected.
If I use the following testcase:
Group1: Limit to default language
- User 1: Nothing selected
Group2: Limit to 2nd language
- User2: Nothing selected
it works as expected. I will check if I find the cause for this strange behavior.
Greets, Sebastian
Updated by Sebastian Kurfuerst almost 18 years ago
I have to revise myself... It seems I had some error in my previous configuration.
I tested it again and again and I can not confirm the above issue.
I'd like to have more information on the issue, preferably a t3d export file.
Greets,
Sebastian
Updated by
Updated by Dmitry Pikhno almost 18 years ago
in testcase
- User 1: Limit to default language
- User 2: Limit to 2nd language
User2 can not edit CE with default language but he is able to delete it.
Updated by Basti Baumann over 17 years ago
Hi,
testcase with 3 languages (english = default).
One user is related to language 3 (dutch) and he can´t edit the default language entries, but he is able to delete entries and to create new one.
TYPO3 Version 4.1.1
Updated by Helmut Hummel over 17 years ago
I cannot confirm the original bug description! A user, which is limited to the default language cannot edit records of another language, as they are hidden for him in the backend.
But I can confirm what Christian, Dimitry and Basti noted, which is the other way around. A user which is limited to a language (which is not default), can delete or move a record of the default language, but cannot hide/unhide or edit it.
So this is bug is somehow related to 0001678 as Christian already mentioned.
Updated by Benni Mack almost 17 years ago
Hey Helmut,
so if this bug is not reproducable and #15114 is now in the latest beta, I think we're all set here and can close this one?
Updated by Helmut Hummel almost 17 years ago
Hey Benni,
I checked again, and still cannot reproduce the described issue. I would close this bug, since the original poster did not give any feedback. This was either no problem at all or got fixed by fixing #15114.
Updated by Benni Mack almost 17 years ago
Unable to reproduce this issue with the latest trunk version.